They call this evidence?
Thursday, October 17, 2013 at 9:53 The Irish Cancer Society has released a video to persuade people of the need for 'plain' packaging of tobacco.
This is evidence, apparently, that the measure will stop children smoking.
James Reilly, Ireland's health minister who is on a personal crusade to rid the country of pesky smokers, responded in the manner you might expect:
The Minister for Health Dr James Reilly TD has strongly welcomed the publication of a new video by the Irish Cancer Society which clearly demonstrates the effect of tobacco packaging on young children.
In the video a group of children is invited to give their views on two different types of packaging: – the current packs used by the tobacco industry and, secondly standardised packaging with significantly increased health warnings.
Currently tobacco companies are entitled to have cigarette packets of different shapes and sizes, with colourful branding, tailored to be attractive to groups including young prospective smokers. In the video the children can be seen to describe the attractiveness of the packs.
But when the children are presented with the cigarettes in standardised packaging, which carry massive health warnings and greatly reduce the potential for the tobacco companies to press their brand, the children declare themselves disgusted by the packaging. The children are seen questioning why it is that people begin to smoke at all.
It is a dramatic demonstration of precisely what the Irish Government hopes to achieve. Minister Reilly has secured the agreement of the Cabinet to introduce standardised packaging for tobacco products in Ireland.
Minister Reilly is clear that the intention of introducing standardised packaging is to make young people think twice before they start to smoke. International evidence shows that most people who start to smoke do so under the aged of 18 years.
Dr Reilly said “If we can put young people off smoking, even for a couple of years, the evidence suggests that they may not develop this killer addiction at all. This video is fascinating in that it shows clearly the degree to which the children are repelled by standardised packaging and more importantly express negative views about the smoking habit.
"I would encourage as many people as possible to watch this video. I will shortly go to Cabinet with the heads of legislation to introduce standardised packaging in Ireland and I look forward to the day when Irish children will refuse to take up a habit which kills one in two smokers.”
I too would encourage as many people as possible to watch this video because it demonstrates the depths to which the tobacco control industry, aided and abetted by politicians like James Reilly, will sink to stigmatise a legal product.
The Journal.ie has the story here – Tallaght schoolchildren have their say on new cigarette packaging.
PS. A few weeks ago the Irish Cancer Society also published a report about the effects of plain packaging on teenagers.
Prompted by Chris Snowdon, Forest Eireann's John Mallon wrote about it here – Truth behind that Irish Cancer Society plain packs study.
What neither John nor Chris mentioned was the fact that the 'study' was based on the views of just 24 people.
Reader Comments (2)
These are under 10 year olds, most of whom wouldn't even consider starting smoking for several years. Still, the seed may have been firmly planted in some of their minds....they should revisit this when the kids are young teenagers.
Given that others are exploiting the TC template, how long before the 'experiment' will be used to promote plain packaging of sweets, junk food and fizzy drinks? I think we also know what the outcome of those would be..
Note the conflation towards the end of Reily propaganda piece:
"If we can put young people off smoking.... ".
It is a regular trick of TC to conflate 'children' and 'young people'. Children will obviously be 'terrified' by grotty pictures. Young adults will not.
The propaganda gets sillier and sillier.