Tory co-chair supported amendment to indoor pub smoking ban

Congratulations to Nigel Huddleston MP who Kemi Badenoch has appointed co-chair of the Conservative Party.

Curiously, one of his first tasks was to defend her opposition to a ban on smoking outside pubs.

“Kemi believes in individual personal responsibility and has got great concerns about government coming in and burdening business,” he told Sky News, adding that he was “glad” the plan for a ban on smoking in pub gardens had been dropped.

Funnily enough, although I’ve never met him, Huddleston did once declare his support for the Forest-led campaign to amend the smoking ban to allow designated smoking rooms in pubs and clubs.

In November 2009, while standing as a prospective parliamentary candidate for Luton South (a seat he didn’t win), the future MP for Droitwich and Evesham joined us at a pub in the town.

As I wrote at the following day:

Yesterday, at the invitation of the local Licensed Victuallers Association (LVA) which represents independent licensees, we held a Save Our Pubs & Clubs meeting at The Bramingham pub in Luton.

The meeting was well attended and we made some very useful contacts including Nigel Huddleston, Conservative PPC for Luton South, who even donned a SOPAC t-shirt for the obligatory photograph.

Registering his support for our campaign, Nigel told a colleague: "We've had enough of Gordon Brown's nanny state. Politicians should respect people's freedom to choose."

I doubt that any leading Conservative would advocate an amendment to the existing pub smoking ban today (that ship has sailed), but it’s good to know there are some senior Tories who still believe in personal responsibility and the freedom to choose.

Sadly, the only evidence I have of that meeting in Luton is a small, poor quality image of Huddleston gamely pulling a pint accompanied by a member of staff and Sean Spillane of Luton Social Club (see below).

Sean is retired now but I remember our first meeting because it was the first time I had been to a working men’s club.

See also: The fascinating story of Britain’s working men’s clubs

Small victories

We returned on Sunday from our seven-night cruise to Lisbon.

Our ship, Cunard’s Queen Anne, docked at Southampton early in the morning and after a quick breakfast we disembarked and were home in Cambridgeshire before eleven.

(That’s the advantage of sailing from Southampton. Unlike flying, with its tiresome airports and endless queues, you can be on and off a ship quite quickly, and with valet parking you can drive right up to the terminal.)

I would write more about the Queen Anne, the latest addition to Cunard’s fleet of (four) ships, but there’s no time at present.

Yesterday, after collecting our dog Roly from kennels, I had to catch a train to London to attend a tobacco-related lunch at the House of Lords.

The timing of the event was perfect because rumours were flying around that the Tobacco and Vapes Bill was to be published today (Tuesday).

Those rumours proved to be true, but more on that later.

First, I had to leave the lunch early because I was booked to do an interview for BBC Spotlight, the local news programme that covers the south west including Devon and Cornwall.

As it happens, I agreed to do the interview via Zoom three weeks ago, but when the producer heard I was going to be in London we arranged to do it at the Millbank studios that are just across the road from the Houses of Parliament.

In the event we did it outside in Victoria Tower Gardens, which is opposite Millbank and directly adjacent to the House of Lords.

The original reason for the interview was a report suggesting that Totteridge, a deprived area in Devon, has a higher than average rate of smoking, and I was asked for my thoughts on that.

However, with the Tobacco and Vapes Bill about to be published, I was asked about that too.

I then caught a train back to Cambridgeshire but when I got home I discovered there was an issue with Roly and I had to take him to the vet.

I won’t go into details but because it was after hours it required a visit to an emergency vet.

As I write he is currently on the sofa looking a bit sorry for himself but hopefully it’s nothing too serious.

Anyway, it’s six in the morning and I have woken up to find that the Government is indeed publishing the Tobacco and Vapes Bill today.

The good news, confirming recent reports, is that a ban on smoking outside hospitality venues will NOT be included in the Bill.

Instead the smoking ban will be extended to places where children are present - outside schools and playgrounds - but also hospitals, something Forest has fought against for many years.

The Bill however is arguably worse for vapers because the Government wants to have a discussion about banning vaping in certain public places.

In truth, while I oppose vaping bans, I have no sympathy for the many vapers (and vaping advocates) who sat on their hands and said nothing when it was announced that the Government wanted to ban smoking outside pubs.

The threat of public vaping bans is the inevitable ‘reward’ for their silence.

Anyway, you might think Forest would be inundated with requests for interviews or comment but that’s not happened.

Instead the ‘story’ is a complete stitch-up. The Government press release - embargoed no doubt until midnight last night - has been reported widely but with almost no comments opposing the Bill.

To date I’ve seen one quote by UKHospitality’s Kate Nicholls and that’s it.

Chris Whitty, the chief medical officer for England, is as prominent as ever, writing in The Times that children have to be “protected” from tobacco smoke, even outside.

Since I’ve yet to see any evidence of harm to non-smokers (including children) from exposure to tobacco smoke in the open air, it is truly staggering that anyone can make this claim and get away with it without some push back, but that’s where we are and few people want to challenge it.

ASH is also prominent in today’s reports but that’s to be expected. Not only are they quoted in the Government press release, they were described recently as one of the Government’s ‘partners’ (I kid you not).

I know that ASH and the Department of Health have enjoyed a close relationship for many years, but ‘partners’? That’s quite an admission.

Anyway, the Tobacco and Vapes Bill will now proceed through Parliament and given the Government’s huge majority there is nothing that can derail it.

Amendments may be tabled - raising the age of sale of tobacco to 21 instead of a generational ban, for example - but the chances of the Bill being watered down are small to non-existent.

Nevertheless, let’s enjoy the fact that plans for a ban on smoking outside pubs have not been included in the Bill. That’s a small victory at least, although I doubt it’s the last we’ve heard of it.

The omission of a tobacco levy in last week’s Budget was another little victory, so although the outlook for smokers under this Government is bleak the anti-smoking lobby hasn’t got everything it wants … for now.

All at sea on tobacco and vapes

I am currently at sea, sailing from Lisbon to Gijon in north west Spain before returning to Southampton on Sunday.

Our home for the week is the Queen Anne, the newest Cunard ship. Launched earlier this year, it’s one of four Cunard ships, the others being Queen Mary 2, Queen Victoria, and Queen Elizabeth.

Queen Anne is not the largest Cunard ship (Queen Mary 2, an ocean liner built for transatlantic cruises, holds that distinction) but it accommodates more passengers - 2,996 compared to QM2 (2,695).

Queen Elizabeth and Queen Victoria are smaller, holding 2,081 passengers apiece.

To put those numbers in perspective, many cruise ships now accommodate upwards of 4,000 passengers, with the largest - the Royal Caribbean's Icon of the Seas - accommodating 5,610 guests (plus 2,350 crew members).

The reason I mention all this is because we were in Lisbon yesterday when the Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, was announcing the details of her first Budget.

You can read Forest’s response to the predictable increase in tobacco duty here, but more noteworthy, perhaps, is the additional “one-off” hike in tobacco duty that will accompany the introduction of a flat rate tax on eliquid from October 2026.

According to the BBC:

That will be accompanied by an equivalent increase of £2.20 per 100 cigarettes in tobacco duty to "maintain the financial incentive to switch from tobacco to vaping".

But that’s not the end of it. Include VAT and the ‘one-off’ tax hike will actually add £3.30 per 100 cigarettes (or 66 pence per 20).

That of course is in addition to the annual tobacco escalator (inflation plus two per cent) that, following yesterday’s Budget, has added something like 54 pence to a pack of 20 cigarettes, and £2.33 to a 30g pouch of handrolling tobacco.

Anyway, Forest’s response was reported by The Sun and the Mirror so my efforts from the quayside in Lisbon weren’t entirely in vain.

Below: On board Cunard’s Queen Anne awaiting the Budget

Reality check as Number Ten reconsiders outdoor pub smoking ban

Good news.

It was reported last night that the Government is to drop its plan to ban smoking outside pubs, including beer gardens.

Nothing has been confirmed but if it’s true it’s a victory for common sense, and everyone who has been arguing against the policy.

I don’t think the issue will go away, though. After all, it’s been around for a decade at least and is currently being pushed by none other than the Chief Medical Officer Chris Whitty who seems to be on a personal mission to eradicate smoking.

Nor does it stop the devolved governments in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland introducing the policy, should they choose to.

In the meantime health secretary Wes Streeting continues to promise a “tougher” version of Rishi Sunak’s Tobacco and Vapes Bill so nothing can be ruled out, including bans on smoking in other outdoor areas.

Funnily enough it's exactly ten years since Boris Johnson was urged, as mayor of London, to ban smoking in the city’s parks, a suggestion he rejected on the grounds that the plan was too interventionist:

“One of the glories of London is that we are generally pretty laissez-faire about how people live their lives – provided they do not break the law and provided they do no harm to others,” he said.

He said he might act on the [London Health] commission’s advice but only if he was convinced that doing so would save lives. “If we were to consider a ban on smoking in parks, we would need pretty clear evidence that this would have direct health benefits – in other words that it would actually save lives. It is time for London to have that debate.”

The reality is that no such evidence exists, as even Number Ten appears to admit, although that’s never stopped governments in the past. 

I’ve no doubt that the existential threat to the hospitality industry has influenced government thinking, but public opinion - as evidenced by a recent poll commissioned by Forest and reported by Guido Fawkes and The Sun - was clearly divided on the issue, with slightly more people being against the idea than in favour.

As for the timing of the Government’s alleged u-turn, can it be coincidence that it was reported just 48 hours after our Smoke On The Water reception attended by MPs and a host of parliamentary aides, including Labour staffers?

Or that one of our speakers was a prominent young Labour activist who opposed the policy on the grounds that it was fundamentally “illiberal”?

Anyway, the battle is not yet won and there are other significant challenges, notably the generational ban on the sale of tobacco, so it's back to work, beginning with an interview on GB News later this morning.

See also: Pub garden smoking ban set to be DROPPED by No 10 (The Sun)
No 10 blocking outdoor smoking ban amid hospitality opposition (Guardian)
Labour ‘will drop plans for outdoor smoking ban’ (Telegraph)
Government refuses to comment on reports of it dropping proposed outdoor smoking ban (Sky News)

Smoke On The Water 2024

Some images from Smoke On The Water 2024.

They include (above, top right) Mitchell Orchant, founder and director, C.Gars Limited; (above, bottom left) Tom Utley, columnist, Daily Mail; and (directly below) Reform MP Lee Anderson.

Below (clockwise from top left): Reem Ibrahim, Institute of Economic Affairs; Josh Cheshire, UK national coordinator, Students for Liberty; Jonathan Heywood, former secretary, Labour Students; and Sam Bidwell, Next Generation Centre at the Adam Smith Institute.

Click here for the full gallery.

For me, though, the photo below is the one that arguably reflects the convivial mood of the evening.

Photos: Stuart Mitchell

Messing about on the river

Thanks to everyone who joined us for Smoke On The Water last night.

Over 220 people registered for the event - our first boat party since 2017 - but the number who actually attended was nearer 180, just short of capacity (200), so that worked out quite well.

I think the evening was a success. Everyone I spoke to seemed to enjoy it.

From the moment guests embarked at Westminster Pier at 7.15 there was a hubbub of excited chatter that was great to hear, but the downside was it drowned out our speakers who struggled to be heard above the noise.

I could, I suppose, have asked that people stopped talking for ten or 15 minutes, but the party was in full swing and it seemed a bit authoritarian to insist that they listen in respectful silence.

It would have been a losing battle anyway, but it reminded me that this was one of the reasons we replaced the boat party with events such as lunches and dinners where guests are sitting down.

For what it’s worth, the four people we invited to say a few words are all in their twenties, which was deliberate because we wanted to make the point that it’s the younger generation that will be hit hardest by the government’s anti-smoking policies (that won’t end with smoking, by the way).

Reem Ibrahim needed little introduction. A familiar face on GB News and TalkTV, the IEA’s acting director of communications is a brilliant and highly articulate communicator and we’re fortunate she’s on our side!

The other speakers were Sam Bidwell, director of the Next Generation Centre at the Adam Smith Institute; Josh Cheshire, national coordinator for Students for Liberty in the UK; and Jonathan Heywood, a leading young Labour activist.

I met Jonathan at the Labour Party conference in Liverpool after he contacted me to say he was building a ‘network of members and officers of the party’s youth and students networks who are opposed to criminalising social smoking’.

We’ll be watching his progress with interest and I hope he succeeds.

Last night however our principal target audience were parliamentary staffers of all parties, and I’m pleased to say they were well represented.

Over 60 had registered, each one working for an MP from one of the four main parties - Conservative, Labour, Lib Dem, and Reform.

Several MPs had registered as well but the most prominent was a latecomer, Reform’s Lee Anderson.

Other guests included broadcasters, journalists, industry lobbyists, think tank staffers, and friends of Forest.

Apologies to everyone I didn’t have a chance to speak to. The evening flew by and before I knew it we were back at Westminster Pier.

The weather played its part because, as well as being dry, it was remarkably balmy for an evening in October.

It meant people could stand on the outside walkways and open deck at the rear of the boat and enjoy the view as we cruised up river from Westminster to Battersea and back.

(Those of us who boarded the boat at Butler’s Wharf near Tower Bridge to prepare for the event had the benefit of an additional 30-minute cruise to Westminster Pier.)

Would we do it again next year? I don’t know. As a social event it was a success. But in terms of getting our message across? I’m not so sure.

PS. The event also featured a four-piece jazz quartet including keyboard, trumpet, and double bass. Unfortunately, they were drowned out too!

Below: the view from the stern of The Elizabethan as we cruised from Butler’s Wharf to Westminster Pier

Linked in

Thanks to the (anonymous) reader who pointed out that most of the links on the right-hand column of this blog weren't working.

It's been fixed now but I can explain.

Clicking on the images of the various reports took you to the old Forest website and I forgot to update them when we launched the new website last month.

If you haven't visited the new website click here. You'll find links to reports, essays, and articles on the Recommended Reading page.

A new section you might like to visit is our Videos and Podcasts page.

We'll upload more in due course but it currently includes podcasts I did with Chris Snowdon (Institute of Economic Affairs) and Benjamin Elks (TaxPayers Alliance).

Chris's podcast (The Swift Half) has since come to a premature end. The reason, according to Chris, was falling viewing/listening figures.

Sorry about that!

Weather watch

I'm pleased to report that Smoke On The Water, the Forest boat party on October 22, is fully booked.

To be honest, I was sceptical we would get anywhere near capacity (200).

One, it's seven years since we last organised a boat party (Smoke On The Water ran annually from 2011 to 2017) and most of our guests during that period have moved on and are no longer working in parliament, or Westminster generally.

Two, Smoke On The Water was a summer boat party, held in June or July, and even then we couldn't guarantee good weather so it was always a bit nerve-wracking.

We had some lovely evenings, with the sun setting behind the London skyline and guests enjoying the open rear deck, but there was one year when it was pretty miserable, weather-wise, although people still seemed to enjoy themselves.

Nevertheless, I put any doubts to one side because, with the Tobacco and Vapes Bill about to be reintroduced to parliament by the new Labour government, it was now or never for a Westminster-based event where we could air our grievances.

As it happens, and despite the recent poor weather, the forecast for Tuesday (in London at least) is pretty good, although I'll believe it when I see it.

(I've been keeping tabs on it for the past week and every day the forecast has changed, which is why I generally ignore them.)

Anyway, I'll keep you posted. Fingers crossed it doesn't rain on the night and we get a full house.